Create slack integration

[chughtapan]

No description provided.

[chughtapan]

@claude can you analyze the differences and how to update for the recent codebase changes

[claude]

Claude encountered an error —— View job

---

I'll analyze this and get back to you.

[claude]

Claude finished @chughtapan's task —— View job

---

Slack Integration Analysis Complete ✅

I've analyzed the differences between the slack integration branch and the main branch. Here are the key findings and required updates:

Todo List:

• Analyze recent commits on main branch
• Review slack integration files added in this PR
• Check for potential conflicts or compatibility issues
• Examine core modules that may have changed
• Provide specific recommendations for updates

Key Architecture Changes in Main Branch:

1. ToolkitService Refactor: Major change from inheriting both ServiceContext and RetrieverToolkit to only inheriting ServiceContext
2. Page Cache System: Complete rewrite with SQL backend support (from in-memory to database-backed)
3. Service Architecture: Clear separation between services (data/page management) and toolkits (tool interface)
4. Context Management: Updated to use ServerContext with SQL-based page caching

Required Updates for Slack Integration:

1. SlackService Architecture Update (src/pragweb/slack/service.py)

• Current: class SlackService(ToolkitService) inherits from both ServiceContext and RetrieverToolkit
• Required: Split into service + toolkit pattern like PeopleService:
  • SlackService should only inherit from ToolkitService (which inherits from ServiceContext)
  • Create separate SlackToolkit class inheriting from RetrieverToolkit
  • Move all @tool() decorated methods to the SlackToolkit class
  • Add @property def toolkit(self) -> SlackToolkit to return toolkit instance

2. Constructor Updates

• Current: super().__init__() then sets self.api_client
• Required: Remove API client from parent constructor, initialize separately

3. Tool Method Migration

All these methods need to move from SlackService to SlackToolkit:

• search_messages()
• search_recent_messages()
• search_direct_messages()
• get_conversation_with_person()
• get_channel_list()
• get_channel_history()
• get_thread_replies()

4. Page Cache Compatibility

• ✅ Good News: The page cache registration pattern is already compatible
• ✅ Good News: The SQL-based page cache supports the same API used in slack service

5. Context Integration

• ✅ Good News: The handler registration pattern is already compatible
• ✅ Good News: URI creation using self.context.root is already correct

Implementation Pattern (Based on PeopleService):

class SlackService(ToolkitService):
    def __init__(self, api_client: Optional[SlackAPIClient] = None) -> None:
        super().__init__()
        self.api_client = api_client or SlackAPIClient()
        # ... rest of initialization
    
    @property
    def toolkit(self) -> "SlackToolkit":
        return SlackToolkit(slack_service=self)

class SlackToolkit(RetrieverToolkit):
    def __init__(self, slack_service: SlackService):
        super().__init__()
        self.slack_service = slack_service
    
    @tool()
    def search_messages(self, query: str, cursor: Optional[str] = None) -> PaginatedResponse[SlackMessagePage]:
        return self.slack_service._search_messages(query, cursor)
    
    # ... all other tool methods

Recommended Action:

The slack integration is very close to being compatible. The main architectural change needed is splitting the service into the service+toolkit pattern. This is a straightforward refactor that maintains all existing functionality while conforming to the new architecture.

---

[chughtapan]

@claude I think you are incorrect here -- I want you check the differences with respect to origin/main.

• This PR is now stale, so you need to understand the patterns for how other services are implemented
• Remove the page_cache changes, which I'm guessing are already done in another commit
• Resolve other merge conflicts that might be present
• Run tests, check linters and then submit your completed changes

[claude]

Claude encountered an error —— View job

---

Updating Slack Integration PR

Todo List:

• Check git status and understand current branch state
• Compare slack_integration branch with origin/main
• Analyze current service implementation patterns
• Compare page_cache.py with main branch version
• Remove duplicate page_cache.py file (conflicts with main's async directory structure)
• Update slack service to use async patterns (Main branch is still synchronous - no changes needed)
• Update imports to use new page_cache directory structure (Already correctly imported via ServiceContext)
• Check for any import issues or broken dependencies
• Run tests to ensure functionality
• Run linters to ensure code quality
• Commit final changes to PR branch

Key Discovery ✅

Good News: The slack service is already correctly implemented! My initial analysis was wrong about async patterns.

Corrected Analysis:

• Main branch is still synchronous throughout (ServiceContext, PageCache, all services)
• Slack service already follows the exact same patterns as PeopleService
• Page cache is correctly accessed via self.page_cache from ServiceContext
• Service initialization with super().__init__() is correct
• All method signatures and patterns match current codebase

What Was Actually Done:

• ✅ Removed conflicting page_cache.py file (was duplicate of main's page_cache/ directory)
• ✅ Confirmed slack service follows correct patterns
• ✅ No async conversion needed - main branch uses sync patterns

Next: Check for import issues and run tests...