You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Auto merge of #41009 - scottmcm:toowned-clone-into, r=alexcrichton
Add a resource-reusing method to `ToOwned`
`ToOwned::to_owned` generalizes `Clone::clone`, but `ToOwned` doesn't have an equivalent to `Clone::clone_from`. This PR adds such a method as `clone_into` under a new unstable feature `toowned_clone_into`.
Analogous to `clone_from`, this has the obvious default implementation in terms of `to_owned`. I've updated the `libcollections` impls: for `T:Clone` it uses `clone_from`, for `[T]` I moved the code from `Vec::clone_from` and implemented that in terms of this, and for `str` it's a predictable implementation in terms of `[u8]`.
Used it in `Cow::clone_from` to reuse resources when both are `Cow::Owned`, and added a test that `Cow<str>` thus keeps capacity in `clone_from` in that situation.
The obvious question: is this the right place for the method?
- It's here so it lives next to `to_owned`, making the default implementation reasonable, and avoiding another trait. But allowing method syntax forces a name like `clone_into`, rather than something more consistent like `owned_from`.
- Another trait would allow `owned_from` and could support multiple owning types per borrow type. But it'd be another single-method trait that generalizes `Clone`, and I don't know how to give it a default impl in terms of `ToOwned::to_owned`, since a blanket would mean overlapping impls problems.
I did it this way as it's simpler and many of the `Borrow`s/`AsRef`s don't make sense with `owned_from` anyway (`[T;1]:Borrow<[T]>`, `Arc<T>:Borrow<T>`, `String:AsRef<OsStr>`...). I'd be happy to re-do it the other way, though, if someone has a good solution for the default handling.
(I can also update with `CStr`, `OsStr`, and `Path` once a direction is decided.)
0 commit comments