Overhaul frequency management in the specification

Raphael Kubo da Costa · Raphael Kubo da Costa · commit 368aa534177d · 2023-07-25T23:52:19.000+02:00
This commit addresses a few issues with the way frequency management was handled in the specification: 1. "Sampling frequency" was interchangeably used as a number as well as an interval ("sampling frequency bounds"), and the latter was not even properly defined. 2. The actual bounds were not properly defined, and neither was the clamping process that used them. 3. There were too many frequency-related terms in use. Let us start with the changes in the concepts and definitions: - A platform sensor has a sampling frequency, a positive number or null. It represents the frequency at which the platform sensor attempts to retrieve data from the device sensor and it is calculated in an implementation-defined manner based on the `[[frequency]]` of the associated Sensor objects. It is therefore a mixture of the previous "sampling frequency" and "requested sampling frequency" definitions. . How the sampling process works is implementation-defined: it could be polling, or requesting updates at this interval, or something else entirely. - A device sensor has a sampling frequency. It is similar to the above, but operating system or hardware dependent and opaque to this specification. . As such, the device sensor may choose a sampling frequency that differs from the platform sensor's sampling frequency and we have no control over it. - A device sensor MAY report lower and/or upper sampling frequency bounds. With the above, the actual sampling bounds are defined and checked: - A sensor type MUST have lower and upper sampling frequency bounds. The lower bound is "max(implementation-defined value, optional spec-defined value)", and the upper bound is "min(implementation-defined value, optional spec-defined value)". - A new algorithm returns a platform sensor's lower and upper sampling bounds as a tuple "(max(optional device sensor lower bound, sensor type lower bound), min(optional device sensor upper bound, sensor type upper bound))". - A Sensor's `[[frequency]]` is always set to a value within a platform sensor's sampling bounds in "Connect to a sensor" (before that it might not have an associated platform sensor and should be in the "activated" state). - "Set sensor settings" requires that the platform sensor sampling value calculated based on its associated sensors' `[[frequency]]` values lies within its sampling bounds. The "optimal sampling frequency" and "requested sampling frequency" <dfn>s have been removed, and so has the "Find the reporting frequency of a sensor object" algorithm, which addresses point (3). The "Automation" section has only received enough changes to avoid Bikeshed errors and warnings, as the entire section is being rewritten. Related to w3c#463.
diff --git a/index.bs b/index.bs
@@ -466,14 +466,15 @@ etc.
 
 <h4 id="limit-max-frequency" dfn>Limit maximum sampling frequency</h4>
 
-User agents may mitigate certain threats by
-limiting the maximum [=sampling frequency=].
+User agents and [=extension specifications=] may mitigate certain threats by defining a [=sensor
+type=]'s [=sensor type/maximum sampling frequency=].
+
 What upper limit to choose depends on the [=sensor type=],
 the kind of threats the user agent is trying to protect against,
 the expected resources of the attacker, etc.
 
-Limiting the maximum [=sampling frequency=] prevents use cases
-which rely on low latency or high data density.
+Limiting the [=sensor type/maximum sampling frequency=] prevents use cases which rely on low
+latency or high data density.
 
 
 <h4 id="stop-sensor" dfn>Stop the sensor altogether</h4>
@@ -489,9 +490,9 @@ or in a different application.
 
 An alternative to [=limit maximum sampling frequency|limiting the maximum sampling frequency=] is to
 limit the number of [=sensor readings=] delivered to Web application developer,
-regardless of what frequency the sensor is polled at.
+regardless of the [=sampling frequency=].
 This allows use cases which have low latency requirement
-to increase [=sampling frequency=]
+to increase the [=sampling frequency=]
 without increasing the amount of data provided.
 
 Discarding intermediary readings prevents certain use cases,
@@ -721,32 +722,52 @@ define ways to uniquely identify each one.
 
 ## Sampling Frequency and Reporting Frequency ## {#concepts-sampling-and-reporting-frequencies}
 
-For the purpose of this specification, <dfn>sampling frequency</dfn> for a [=platform sensor=] is
-defined as a frequency at which the user agent obtains [=sensor readings=] from the underlying
-platform.
+For the purpose of this specification, a [=platform sensor=]'s <dfn>sampling frequency</dfn> is
+defined as a frequency at which a [=platform sensor=] obtains [=sensor readings=] from the
+underlying [=device sensor=]. The way such [=sensor readings=] are obtained is
+[=implementation-defined=].
 
-The user agent can request the underlying platform to deliver [=sensor readings|readings=] at a certain
-rate which is called <dfn>requested sampling frequency</dfn>.
+Note: The user agent can, for example, poll the operating system/[=device sensor=], or register for
+operating system notifications.
 
-The [=sampling frequency=] is equal to the [=requested sampling frequency=] if the underlying platform
-can support it.
+The [=platform sensor=]'s [=sampling frequency=] may not correspond to the [=device sensor=]'s
+actual sampling rate, which, for the purpose of this specification, is opaque.
 
-The [=sampling frequency=] differs from the [=requested sampling frequency=] in the following cases:
- - the [=requested sampling frequency=] exceeds upper or lower [=sampling frequency=] bounds
-   supported by the underlying platform.
- - the operating system and/or the [=device sensor=] automatically discard
-   readings that do not differ enough (in absolute or relative terms) from the
-   previously reported ones via a hardware or operating system filter.
- - the [=platform sensor=]'s associated [=sensor type=]'s [=threshold check
-   algorithm=] fails and the [=platform sensor=]'s [=latest readings=] are not
-   updated.
+A [=device sensor=] may provide bounds for the sampling frequency value it can accept from a
+[=platform sensor=] in the form of a <dfn for="device sensor">minimum sampling frequency</dfn> and a
+<dfn for= "device sensor">maximum sampling frequency</dfn>. A [=platform sensor=]'s [=sampling
+frequency=] must not be less than the [=device sensor=]'s [=device sensor/minimum sampling
+frequency=] or greater than its [=device sensor/maximum sampling frequency=].
+
+A [=platform sensor=]'s [=sampling frequency=] is determined based on the provided
+{{Sensor/[[frequency]]}} of the [=set/items=] in its [=ordered set|set=] of [=activated sensor
+objects=]. The calculation is [=implementation-defined=], but the outcome value must lie within the
+bounds set by the [=platform sensor=]'s [=sensor type=]'s [=sensor type/minimum sampling
+frequency|minimum=] and [=sensor type/maximum sampling frequency|maximum=] sampling frequencies and
+its [=device sensor=]'s [=device sensor/minimum sampling frequency|minimum=] and [=device
+sensor/maximum sampling frequency|maximum=] sampling frequencies.
+
+Note: For example, the user agent may estimate the [=sampling frequency=] as a Least Common
+Denominator (LCD) for a set of provided {{Sensor/[[frequency]]}} capped by [=sampling frequency=]
+bounds defined by the underlying platform.
 
 The <dfn>reporting frequency</dfn> for a concrete {{Sensor}} object is defined as a frequency at which
 the "reading" event is [=fire an event|fired=] at this object.
 
 A {{Sensor}} object cannot access new [=sensor readings|readings=] at a higher rate than the
 user agent obtains them from the underlying platform, therefore the [=reporting frequency=] can
-never exceed the [=sampling frequency=] for the given [=sensor type=].
+never exceed a [=platform sensor=]'s [=sampling frequency=], which in turn can never exceed a
+[=device sensor=]'s [=device sensor/maximum sampling frequency=] (when specified).
+
+The [=reporting frequency=] differs from the {{Sensor}}'s {{Sensor/[[frequency]]}} in cases such as:
+ - the requested {{Sensor/[[frequency]]}} lies outside the bounds returned by invoking [=get a
+   platform sensor's sampling bounds=] with {{Sensor}}'s associated [=platform sensor=].
+ - the operating system and/or the [=device sensor=] automatically discard
+   readings that do not differ enough (in absolute or relative terms) from the
+   previously reported ones via a hardware or operating system filter.
+ - the {{Sensor}} instance's associated [=sensor type=]'s [=threshold check
+   algorithm=] fails and the [=platform sensor=]'s [=latest readings=] are not
+   updated.
 
 ## Conditions to expose sensor readings ## {#concepts-can-expose-sensor-readings}
 
@@ -781,6 +802,15 @@ A <dfn>sensor type</dfn> must have the following associated data:
 - An [=set/is empty|nonempty=] [=ordered set=] of associated [=policy-controlled feature=] tokens
   referred to as <dfn export>sensor feature names</dfn>.
 - A [=permission revocation algorithm=].
+- A <dfn export for="sensor type">minimum sampling frequency</dfn>, a positive number. It is either
+  [=implementation-defined=] or defined by an [=extension specification=]. If both are set, the
+  largest value is used.
+- A <dfn export for="sensor type">maximum sampling frequency</dfn>, a positive number. It is either
+  [=implementation-defined=] or defined by an [=extension specification=]. If both are set, the
+  smallest value is used.
+
+The [=sensor type/minimum sampling frequency=] must not be greater than the [=sensor type/maximum
+sampling frequency=].
 
 A [=sensor type=] may have the following associated data:
 - A [=default sensor=].
@@ -839,17 +869,21 @@ Note: There are additional privacy concerns when using cached [=sensor readings|
 which predate either [=navigating=] to resources in the current [=origin=],
 or being granted permission to access the [=platform sensor=]. -->
 
-A [=platform sensor=] has an associated [=requested sampling frequency=] which is initially null.
-
-For a non-[=set/is empty|empty=] [=ordered set|set=] of [=activated sensor objects=] the
-[=requested sampling frequency=] is equal to the <dfn>optimal sampling frequency</dfn>, which is estimated
-by the user agent by taking into account the {{[[frequency]]|provided frequencies}}
-of [=activated sensor objects|activated=] {{Sensor|Sensors}} and the [=sampling frequency=] bounds
-defined by the underlying platform.
-
-Note: For example, the user agent may estimate [=optimal sampling frequency=] as a Least Common
-Denominator (LCD) for a set of {{[[frequency]]|provided frequencies}} capped
-by [=sampling frequency=] bounds defined by the underlying platform.
+<div algorithm>
+To <dfn>get a platform sensor's sampling bounds</dfn> given a [=platform sensor=]
+|platformSensor|:
+  1.  Let |minimumFrequency| be |platformSensor|'s [=sensor type=]'s [=sensor type/minimum sampling
+      frequency=].
+  1.  If |platformSensor|'s connected [=device sensor=] has a [=device sensor/minimum sampling
+      frequency=], set |minimumFrequency| to the maximum of |minimumFrequency| and the [=device
+      sensor/minimum sampling frequency=].
+  1.  Let |maximumFrequency| be |platformSensor|'s [=sensor type=]'s [=sensor type/maximum sampling
+      frequency=].
+  1.  If |platformSensor|'s connected [=device sensor=] has a [=device sensor/maximum sampling
+      frequency=], set |maximumFrequency| to the minimum of |maximumFrequency| and the [=device
+      sensor/maximum sampling frequency=].
+  1.  Return a [=tuple=] (|minimumFrequency|, |maximumFrequency|).
+</div>
 
 <div class=example>
 
@@ -866,7 +900,7 @@ The {{Sensor}} object in "idle" [[#sensor-lifecycle|state]] is not among the [=p
 In this example there is a [=platform sensor=] instance per [=browsing context=].
 
 The [=latest reading=] [=ordered map|map=] is shared between {{Sensor}} objects from the
-same [=browsing context|context=] and is updated at a rate equal to the [=requested sampling frequency=]
+same [=browsing context|context=] and is updated at a rate equal to the requested [=sampling frequency=]
 of the corresponding [=platform sensor=].
 
 </div>
@@ -1063,12 +1097,10 @@ with the internal slots described in the following table:
         <tr>
             <td><dfn attribute for=Sensor>\[[frequency]]</dfn></td>
             <td>A double representing frequency in Hz that is used to calculate
-                the [=requested sampling frequency=] for the associated [=platform sensor=]
+                the [=sampling frequency=] for the associated [=platform sensor=]
                 and to define the upper bound of the [=reporting frequency=] for this
-                {{Sensor}} object.
-
-                This slot holds the provided {{SensorOptions}}.{{frequency!!dict-member}} value.
-                It is initially unset.</td>
+                {{Sensor}} object. It is initially null.
+            </td>
         </tr>
         <tr>
             <td><dfn attribute for=Sensor>\[[lastEventFiredAt]]</dfn></td>
@@ -1256,8 +1288,8 @@ to {{SensorErrorEventInit}}.
         1.  Set |sensor_instance|.{{[[frequency]]}} to |options|["{{frequency!!dict-member}}"].
 
         Note: There is no guarantee that the requested |options|["{{frequency!!dict-member}}"]
-        can be respected. The actual [=sampling frequency=] can be calculated using
-        {{Sensor}} {{Sensor/timestamp!!attribute}} attributes.
+        can be respected. See [[#concepts-sampling-and-reporting-frequencies]] for constraints that
+        may be applied.
 </div>
 
 <h3 dfn export>Check sensor policy-controlled features</h3>
@@ -1283,24 +1315,30 @@ to {{SensorErrorEventInit}}.
 <div algorithm="connect to sensor">
 
     : input
-    :: |sensor_instance|, a {{Sensor}} object.
+    :: |sensor|, a {{Sensor}} object.
     : output
-    :: True if sensor instance was associated with a [=platform sensor=],
+    :: True if |sensor| was associated with a [=platform sensor=],
        false otherwise.
 
-    1.  Let |type| be the [=sensor type=] of |sensor_instance|.
+    1.  Let |platformSensor| be null.
+    1.  Let |type| be |sensor|'s associated [=sensor type=].
     1.  If the device has a single [=device sensor=] which can provide [=sensor readings|readings=]
         for |type|, then
-        1.  Associate |sensor_instance| with a [=platform sensor=] corresponding
+        1.  Set |platformSensor| to a [=platform sensor=] corresponding
             to this [=device sensor=].
-        1.  Return true.
     1.  If the device has multiple [=device sensors=] which can provide [=sensor readings|readings=]
         for |type|, then
         1.  If |type| has an associated [=default sensor=], then
-            1.  Associate |sensor_instance| with a [=platform sensor=] corresponding
-                to [=default sensor=].
-            1.  Return true.
-    1.  Return false.
+            1.  Set |platformSensor| to a [=platform sensor=] corresponding
+                to this [=default sensor|default device sensor=].
+    1.  If |platformSensor| is null, return false.
+    1.  Let |bounds| be the result of invoking [=get a platform sensor's sampling bounds=] with
+        |platformSensor|.
+    1.  If |sensor|.{{Sensor/[[frequency]]}} is null, set it to an [=implementation-defined=] value
+        dependent on |type|.
+    1.  If |sensor|.{{Sensor/[[frequency]]}} is less than |bounds|[0], set it to |bounds|[0].
+    1.  If |sensor|.{{Sensor/[[frequency]]}} is greater than |bounds|[1], set it to |bounds|[1].
+    1.  Return true.
 </div>
 
 <h3 dfn export>Activate a sensor object</h3>
@@ -1361,18 +1399,24 @@ to {{SensorErrorEventInit}}.
 <div algorithm="set sensor settings">
 
     : input
-    :: |sensor|, a [=platform sensor=].
+    :: |platformSensor|, a [=platform sensor=].
     : output
     :: None
 
-    1.  If |sensor|'s set of [=activated sensor objects=] [=set/is empty=],
-        1.  Set [=requested sampling frequency=] to null.
-        1.  [=map/For each=] |key| → <var ignore>value</var> of [=latest reading=].
-            1.  [=map/Set=] [=latest reading=][|key|] to null.
-        1.  Update the user-agent-specific way in which [=sensor readings=] are obtained from |sensor|
-            to no longer provide [=sensor readings|readings=].
+    1.  If |platformSensor|'s set of [=activated sensor objects=] [=set/is empty=],
+        1.  Set |platformSensor|'s [=sampling frequency=] to null.
+        1.  [=map/For each=] |key| → <var ignore>value</var> of |platformSensor|'s [=latest reading=].
+            1.  [=map/Set=] |platformSensor|'s [=latest reading=][|key|] to null.
+        1.  Update the [=implementation-defined=] way in which [=sensor readings=] are obtained
+            from |platformSensor| to no longer provide [=sensor readings|readings=].
         1.  Return.
-    1.  Set [=requested sampling frequency=] to [=optimal sampling frequency=].
+    1.  Set |platformSensor|'s [=sampling frequency=] to an [=implementation-defined=] value based
+        on the {{Sensor/[[frequency]]}} values of the items in its [=activated sensor objects=]
+        [=ordered set|set=].
+    1.  Let |bounds| be the result of invoking [=get a platform sensor's sampling bounds=] with
+        |platformSensor|.
+    1.  [=Assert=]: |platformSensor|'s [=sampling frequency=] is greater than or equal to
+        |bounds|[0] and less than or equal to |bounds|[1].
 </div>
 
 <h3 dfn export>Update latest reading</h3>
@@ -1400,25 +1444,6 @@ to {{SensorErrorEventInit}}.
             1.  Invoke [=report latest reading updated=] with |s| as an argument.
 </div>
 
-<h3 dfn export>Find the reporting frequency of a sensor object</h3>
-
-<div algorithm="find the reporting frequency of a sensor object">
-
-    : input
-    :: |sensor_instance|, a {{Sensor}} object.
-    : output
-    :: [=reporting frequency=] in Hz.
-
-    1.  Let |frequency| be null.
-    1.  Let |f| be |sensor_instance|.{{[[frequency]]}}.
-        1. if |f| is set,
-            1. set |frequency| to |f| capped by the upper and lower [=sampling frequency=]
-               bounds for the associated [=platform sensor=].
-        1.  Otherwise,
-            1. user agent can assign |frequency| to an appropriate value.
-    1. return |frequency|.
-</div>
-
 <h3 dfn export>Report latest reading updated</h3>
 
 <div algorithm="report latest reading updated">
@@ -1435,11 +1460,9 @@ to {{SensorErrorEventInit}}.
     1.  If |lastReportedTimestamp| is not set
         1.  Queue a task to run [=notify new reading=] with |sensor_instance| as an argument.
         1.  Return.
-    1.  Let |reportingFrequency| be result of invoking [=Find the reporting frequency of a sensor object=].
-    1.  If |reportingFrequency| is null
-        1.  Queue a task to run [=notify new reading=] with |sensor_instance| as an argument.
-        1.  Return.
-    1.  Let |reportingInterval| be the result of 1 / |reportingFrequency|.
+    1.  [=Assert=]: |sensor_instance|.{{Sensor/[[frequency]]}} is not null.
+    1.  [=Assert=]: |sensor_instance|.{{Sensor/[[frequency]]}} is greater than 0.
+    1.  Let |reportingInterval| be the result of 1 / |sensor_instance|.{{Sensor/[[frequency]]}}.
     1.  Let |timestampDelta| be the result of [=latest reading=]["timestamp"] - |lastReportedTimestamp|.
     1.  If  |timestampDelta| is greater than or equal to |reportingInterval|
         1.  Queue a task to run [=notify new reading=] with |sensor_instance| as an argument.
@@ -1566,13 +1589,10 @@ and whose initial [=map/values=] are implementation-dependent.
 
 Note: The user agent must provide the [=mock sensor reading=] that are initially exposed to the {{Sensor}} objects.
 
-A [=mock sensor=] has an associated [=requested sampling frequency=]. Its default value is implementation-dependent
-but must be set within a [=mock sensor=]'s associated [=sampling frequency=] bounds.
-
 A [=mock sensor=] has an associated [=sampling frequency=] with supported bounds. The default values of
 supported bounds are implementation-dependent.
 
-A [=mock sensor=] must report the [=mock sensor reading=] at the rate of its [=requested sampling frequency=]
+A [=mock sensor=] must report the [=mock sensor reading=] at the rate of its [=sampling frequency=]
 if the user agent [=can expose sensor readings=] to the [=current browsing context=]'s [=active document=].
 
 Note: The [=mock sensor=] defined in this specification is not intended be used by non-testing-related web content.
@@ -1624,7 +1644,7 @@ The {{MockSensor}} dictionary provides information about a [=mock sensor=].
 :: A double representing frequency in Hz that indicates the minimum supported [=sampling frequency=] of the associated [=mock sensor=].
 
 : {{MockSensor/requestedSamplingFrequency}} member
-:: A double representing frequency in Hz that indicates the [=requested sampling frequency=] of the associated [=mock sensor=].
+:: A double representing frequency in Hz that indicates the [=sampling frequency=] of the associated [=mock sensor=].
 
 A <dfn>serialized mock sensor</dfn> is a JSON [=Object=] where a [=mock sensor=]'s fields listed in the {{MockSensor}} dictionary are mapped
 using the <i>JSON Key</i> and the associated field's value from the available [=mock sensor=] in [=current browsing context=].
@@ -2002,7 +2022,7 @@ creating multiple instances of the same [=sensor type=] and using simple {{Senso
 handler.
 
 Conversely, multiple {{Sensor|Sensors}} of the same [=sensor type=] can be created when they
-are intended to be used with different settings, such as: [=requested sampling frequency=],
+are intended to be used with different settings, such as: {{SensorOptions/frequency}},
 accuracy or other settings defined in [=extension specifications=].
 
 <h3 id="definition-reqs">Definition Requirements</h3>
