You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
What theoretically desirable properties of type systems is Lean known not to possess (e.g., subject reduction, canonicity, ?) and what are concrete examples of these violations?
Additional context
Searching for these topics on the Lean Zulip returns various long discussions which are not always easy to follow, not least because they often assume context from elsewhere (e.g., Twitter (which is not easy to access for everyone, the Rocq issue tracker (which assumes that you can read Rocq), or Mario Carneiro's thesis (which assumes that you can read type theoretic notation)). In addition, if there are examples, they are often in Lean 3 or no-longer-compiling old Lean 4.
It would be great to have all of these examples in one place together with good explanations, and given that the reference manual is a place to look up the details and it has a chapter on Lean's type system, I thought that this might be in scope for the reference manual.
Examples of code that I think would be great to keep up-to-date and explain in detail are this and this.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
What question should the reference manual answer?
What theoretically desirable properties of type systems is Lean known not to possess (e.g., subject reduction, canonicity, ?) and what are concrete examples of these violations?
Additional context
Searching for these topics on the Lean Zulip returns various long discussions which are not always easy to follow, not least because they often assume context from elsewhere (e.g., Twitter (which is not easy to access for everyone, the Rocq issue tracker (which assumes that you can read Rocq), or Mario Carneiro's thesis (which assumes that you can read type theoretic notation)). In addition, if there are examples, they are often in Lean 3 or no-longer-compiling old Lean 4.
It would be great to have all of these examples in one place together with good explanations, and given that the reference manual is a place to look up the details and it has a chapter on Lean's type system, I thought that this might be in scope for the reference manual.
Examples of code that I think would be great to keep up-to-date and explain in detail are this and this.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: