🐛 Email signing-up (register) not responsive (a case uncovered by current documentation)

[fhfuih]

Is there an existing issue for this?

• I have searched the existing issues and found no duplicates.

What plugin is this bug for?

Firebase UI Auth

What platform(s) does this bug affect?

Android, iOS

List of dependencies used.

flutter pub deps -s list

Dart SDK 3.3.0
Flutter SDK 3.19.2
campus 1.0.0+1
dependencies:

flutter 0.0.0

characters 1.3.0
collection 1.18.0
material_color_utilities 0.8.0
meta 1.11.0
vector_math 2.1.4
sky_engine any


cupertino_icons 1.0.8
flutter_localizations 0.0.0

flutter any
intl 0.18.1
characters 1.3.0
clock 1.1.1
collection 1.18.0
material_color_utilities 0.8.0
meta 1.11.0
path 1.9.0
vector_math 2.1.4


intl 0.18.1

clock ^1.1.0
meta ^1.0.2
path ^1.8.0


go_router 13.2.5

collection ^1.15.0
flutter any
flutter_web_plugins any
logging ^1.0.0
meta ^1.7.0


flutter_dotenv 5.1.0

flutter any


dio 5.4.3+1

async ^2.8.2
http_parser ^4.0.0
meta ^1.5.0
path ^1.8.0


shared_preferences 2.2.3

flutter any
shared_preferences_android ^2.1.0
shared_preferences_foundation ^2.3.5
shared_preferences_linux ^2.2.0
shared_preferences_platform_interface ^2.3.0
shared_preferences_web ^2.1.0
shared_preferences_windows ^2.2.0


cached_network_image 3.3.1

cached_network_image_platform_interface ^4.0.0
cached_network_image_web ^1.1.1
flutter any
flutter_cache_manager ^3.3.1
octo_image ^2.0.0


flutter_svg 2.0.10+1

flutter any
http ^1.0.0
vector_graphics ^1.1.11
vector_graphics_codec ^1.1.11
vector_graphics_compiler ^1.1.11


provider 6.1.2

collection ^1.15.0
flutter any
nested ^1.0.0


flutter_map 6.1.0

async ^2.9.0
collection ^1.17.1
flutter any
http ^1.0.0
latlong2 ^0.9.0
logger ^2.0.1
meta ^1.9.1
polylabel ^1.0.1
proj4dart ^2.1.0
vector_math ^2.1.2


latlong2 0.9.1

intl >=0.15.0 <1.0.0


flutter_map_cache 1.5.0

flutter any
dio_cache_interceptor ^3.4.2
dio ^5.2.0+1
flutter_map ^6.0.0


path_provider 2.1.3

flutter any
path_provider_android ^2.1.0
path_provider_foundation ^2.3.2
path_provider_linux ^2.2.0
path_provider_platform_interface ^2.1.0
path_provider_windows ^2.2.0


dio_cache_interceptor_file_store 1.2.3

dio_cache_interceptor ^3.4.4
path ^1.8.0
synchronized ^3.0.0


dio_cache_interceptor 3.5.0

dio >=5.2.0+1 <6.0.0
uuid >=3.0.7 <5.0.0
string_scanner ^1.1.0


url_launcher 6.2.6

flutter any
url_launcher_android ^6.2.0
url_launcher_ios ^6.2.4
url_launcher_linux ^3.1.0
url_launcher_macos ^3.1.0
url_launcher_platform_interface ^2.2.0
url_launcher_web ^2.2.0
url_launcher_windows ^3.1.0


flutter_map_animations 0.6.0

flutter any
flutter_map ^6.1.0
latlong2 ^0.9.0


geolocator 11.1.0

flutter any
geolocator_platform_interface ^4.1.0
geolocator_android ^4.3.0
geolocator_apple ^2.3.0
geolocator_web ^3.0.0
geolocator_windows ^0.2.2


image_picker 1.1.1

flutter any
image_picker_android ^0.8.7
image_picker_for_web >=2.2.0 <4.0.0
image_picker_ios ^0.8.8
image_picker_linux ^0.2.1
image_picker_macos ^0.2.1
image_picker_platform_interface ^2.10.0
image_picker_windows ^0.2.1


firebase_ui_auth 1.14.0

email_validator ^2.1.17
firebase_auth ^4.17.5
firebase_core ^2.25.4
firebase_dynamic_links ^5.4.14
firebase_ui_localizations ^1.11.0
firebase_ui_oauth ^1.5.2
firebase_ui_shared ^1.4.1
flutter any
flutter_localizations any
meta ^1.10.0


firebase_auth 4.19.6

firebase_auth_platform_interface ^7.2.7
firebase_auth_web ^5.11.6
firebase_core ^2.31.1
firebase_core_platform_interface ^5.0.0
flutter any
meta ^1.8.0


firebase_core 2.31.1

firebase_core_platform_interface ^5.0.0
firebase_core_web ^2.17.0
flutter any
meta ^1.8.0


firebase_dynamic_links 5.5.6

firebase_core ^2.31.1
firebase_core_platform_interface ^5.0.0
firebase_dynamic_links_platform_interface ^0.2.6+34
flutter any
meta ^1.8.0
plugin_platform_interface ^2.1.3



dev dependencies:

flutter_test 0.0.0

flutter any
test_api 0.6.1
matcher 0.12.16+1
path 1.9.0
fake_async 1.3.1
clock 1.1.1
stack_trace 1.11.1
vector_math 2.1.4
leak_tracker_flutter_testing 2.0.1
async 2.11.0
boolean_selector 2.1.1
characters 1.3.0
collection 1.18.0
leak_tracker 10.0.0
leak_tracker_testing 2.0.1
material_color_utilities 0.8.0
meta 1.11.0
source_span 1.10.0
stream_channel 2.1.2
string_scanner 1.2.0
term_glyph 1.2.1
vm_service 13.0.0


flutter_lints 3.0.2

lints ^3.0.0



transitive dependencies:

_flutterfire_internals 1.3.34

collection ^1.0.0
firebase_core ^2.31.1
firebase_core_platform_interface ^5.0.0
flutter any
meta ^1.8.0


args 2.5.0
async 2.11.0

collection ^1.15.0
meta ^1.1.7


boolean_selector 2.1.1

source_span ^1.8.0
string_scanner ^1.1.0


cached_network_image_platform_interface 4.0.0

flutter any
flutter_cache_manager ^3.3.1


cached_network_image_web 1.2.0

cached_network_image_platform_interface ^4.0.0
flutter any
flutter_cache_manager ^3.3.1


characters 1.3.0
clock 1.1.1
collection 1.18.0
cross_file 0.3.4+1

meta ^1.3.0
web ^0.5.0


crypto 3.0.3

typed_data ^1.3.0


desktop_webview_auth 0.0.15

crypto ^3.0.3
flutter any
http ^1.0.0
flutter_web_plugins any
plugin_platform_interface ^2.1.4


email_validator 2.1.17
fake_async 1.3.1

clock ^1.1.0
collection ^1.15.0


ffi 2.1.2
file 7.0.0

meta ^1.9.1
path ^1.8.3


file_selector_linux 0.9.2+1

cross_file ^0.3.1
file_selector_platform_interface ^2.6.0
flutter any


file_selector_macos 0.9.4

cross_file ^0.3.1
file_selector_platform_interface ^2.6.0
flutter any


file_selector_platform_interface 2.6.2

cross_file ^0.3.0
flutter any
http >=0.13.0 <2.0.0
plugin_platform_interface ^2.1.7


file_selector_windows 0.9.3+1

cross_file ^0.3.1
file_selector_platform_interface ^2.6.0
flutter any


firebase_auth_platform_interface 7.2.7

_flutterfire_internals ^1.3.34
collection ^1.16.0
firebase_core ^2.31.1
flutter any
meta ^1.8.0
plugin_platform_interface ^2.1.3


firebase_auth_web 5.11.6

firebase_auth_platform_interface ^7.2.7
firebase_core ^2.31.1
firebase_core_web ^2.17.0
flutter any
flutter_web_plugins any
http_parser ^4.0.0
meta ^1.8.0
web ^0.5.1


firebase_core_platform_interface 5.0.0

collection ^1.0.0
flutter any
flutter_test any
meta ^1.8.0
plugin_platform_interface ^2.1.3


firebase_core_web 2.17.0

firebase_core_platform_interface ^5.0.0
flutter any
flutter_web_plugins any
meta ^1.8.0
web ^0.5.1


firebase_dynamic_links_platform_interface 0.2.6+34

_flutterfire_internals ^1.3.34
firebase_core ^2.31.1
flutter any
meta ^1.8.0
plugin_platform_interface ^2.1.3


firebase_ui_localizations 1.11.0

flutter any
flutter_localizations any
path ^1.8.3


firebase_ui_oauth 1.5.2

desktop_webview_auth ^0.0.14
firebase_auth ^4.17.5
firebase_ui_auth ^1.14.0
firebase_ui_shared ^1.4.1
flutter_svg ^2.0.9
flutter any


firebase_ui_shared 1.4.1

flutter any


fixnum 1.1.0
flutter_cache_manager 3.3.2

clock ^1.1.0
collection ^1.18.0
file ^7.0.0
flutter any
http ^1.2.1
path ^1.9.0
path_provider ^2.1.3
rxdart ^0.27.7
sqflite ^2.3.3
uuid ^4.4.0


flutter_plugin_android_lifecycle 2.0.19

flutter any


flutter_web_plugins 0.0.0

flutter any
characters 1.3.0
collection 1.18.0
material_color_utilities 0.8.0
meta 1.11.0
vector_math 2.1.4


geolocator_android 4.6.0

flutter any
geolocator_platform_interface ^4.1.0
meta ^1.10.0
uuid >=4.0.0 <6.0.0


geolocator_apple 2.3.7

flutter any
geolocator_platform_interface ^4.1.0


geolocator_platform_interface 4.2.3

flutter any
plugin_platform_interface ^2.1.6
vector_math ^2.1.4
meta ^1.9.1


geolocator_web 3.0.0

flutter any
flutter_web_plugins any
geolocator_platform_interface ^4.1.0


geolocator_windows 0.2.3

flutter any
geolocator_platform_interface ^4.1.0


http 1.2.1

async ^2.5.0
http_parser ^4.0.0
meta ^1.3.0
web ^0.5.0


http_parser 4.0.2

collection ^1.15.0
source_span ^1.8.0
string_scanner ^1.1.0
typed_data ^1.3.0


image_picker_android 0.8.12+1

flutter any
flutter_plugin_android_lifecycle ^2.0.1
image_picker_platform_interface ^2.10.0


image_picker_for_web 3.0.4

flutter any
flutter_web_plugins any
image_picker_platform_interface ^2.9.0
mime ^1.0.4
web ^0.5.1


image_picker_ios 0.8.11+2

flutter any
image_picker_platform_interface ^2.10.0


image_picker_linux 0.2.1+1

file_selector_linux ^0.9.1+3
file_selector_platform_interface ^2.2.0
flutter any
image_picker_platform_interface ^2.8.0


image_picker_macos 0.2.1+1

file_selector_macos ^0.9.1+1
file_selector_platform_interface ^2.3.0
flutter any
image_picker_platform_interface ^2.8.0


image_picker_platform_interface 2.10.0

cross_file ^0.3.1+1
flutter any
http >=0.13.0 <2.0.0
plugin_platform_interface ^2.1.7


image_picker_windows 0.2.1+1

file_selector_platform_interface ^2.2.0
file_selector_windows ^0.9.0
flutter any
image_picker_platform_interface ^2.8.0


leak_tracker 10.0.0

clock ^1.1.1
collection ^1.15.0
meta ^1.8.0
path ^1.8.3
vm_service >=11.10.0 <15.0.0


leak_tracker_flutter_testing 2.0.1

flutter any
leak_tracker >=10.0.0 <11.0.0
leak_tracker_testing >=2.0.1 <3.0.0
matcher ^0.12.16
meta ^1.8.0


leak_tracker_testing 2.0.1

leak_tracker >=9.0.0 <11.0.0
matcher ^0.12.16
meta ^1.11.0


lints 3.0.0
lists 1.0.1

meta ^1.3.0


logger 2.3.0
logging 1.2.0
matcher 0.12.16+1

async ^2.10.0
meta ^1.8.0
stack_trace ^1.10.0
term_glyph ^1.2.0
test_api >=0.5.0 <0.8.0


material_color_utilities 0.8.0

collection ^1.15.0


meta 1.11.0
mgrs_dart 2.0.0

unicode ^0.3.0


mime 1.0.5
nested 1.0.0

flutter any


octo_image 2.0.0

flutter any


path 1.9.0
path_parsing 1.0.1

vector_math ^2.1.0
meta ^1.3.0


path_provider_android 2.2.4

flutter any
path_provider_platform_interface ^2.1.0


path_provider_foundation 2.4.0

flutter any
path_provider_platform_interface ^2.1.0


path_provider_linux 2.2.1

ffi >=1.1.2 <3.0.0
flutter any
path ^1.8.0
path_provider_platform_interface ^2.1.0
xdg_directories >=0.2.0 <2.0.0


path_provider_platform_interface 2.1.2

flutter any
platform ^3.0.0
plugin_platform_interface ^2.1.7


path_provider_windows 2.2.1

ffi ^2.0.0
flutter any
path ^1.8.0
path_provider_platform_interface ^2.1.0
win32 >=2.1.0 <6.0.0


petitparser 6.0.2

meta ^1.9.0


platform 3.1.4
plugin_platform_interface 2.1.8

meta ^1.3.0


polylabel 1.0.1

collection ^1.15.0


proj4dart 2.1.0

mgrs_dart ^2.0.0
wkt_parser ^2.0.0
meta ^1.3.0


rxdart 0.27.7
shared_preferences_android 2.2.2

flutter any
shared_preferences_platform_interface ^2.3.0


shared_preferences_foundation 2.4.0

flutter any
shared_preferences_platform_interface ^2.3.0


shared_preferences_linux 2.3.2

file >=6.0.0 <8.0.0
flutter any
path ^1.8.0
path_provider_linux ^2.0.0
path_provider_platform_interface ^2.0.0
shared_preferences_platform_interface ^2.3.0


shared_preferences_platform_interface 2.3.2

flutter any
plugin_platform_interface ^2.1.7


shared_preferences_web 2.3.0

flutter any
flutter_web_plugins any
shared_preferences_platform_interface ^2.3.0
web ^0.5.0


shared_preferences_windows 2.3.2

file >=6.0.0 <8.0.0
flutter any
path ^1.8.0
path_provider_platform_interface ^2.0.0
path_provider_windows ^2.0.0
shared_preferences_platform_interface ^2.3.0


sky_engine 0.0.99
source_span 1.10.0

collection ^1.15.0
path ^1.8.0
term_glyph ^1.2.0


sprintf 7.0.0
sqflite 2.3.3+1

flutter any
sqflite_common >=2.5.0-1 <4.0.0
path >=1.8.0 <3.0.0


sqflite_common 2.5.4

synchronized >=3.0.0 <5.0.0
path >=1.8.0 <3.0.0
meta >=1.3.0 <3.0.0


stack_trace 1.11.1

path ^1.8.0


stream_channel 2.1.2

async ^2.5.0


string_scanner 1.2.0

source_span ^1.8.0


synchronized 3.1.0+1
term_glyph 1.2.1
test_api 0.6.1

async ^2.5.0
boolean_selector ^2.1.0
collection ^1.15.0
meta ^1.3.0
source_span ^1.8.0
stack_trace ^1.10.0
stream_channel ^2.1.0
string_scanner ^1.1.0
term_glyph ^1.2.0


typed_data 1.3.2

collection ^1.15.0


unicode 0.3.1

lists ^1.0.0


url_launcher_android 6.3.2

flutter any
url_launcher_platform_interface ^2.3.1


url_launcher_ios 6.3.0

flutter any
url_launcher_platform_interface ^2.2.0


url_launcher_linux 3.1.1

flutter any
url_launcher_platform_interface ^2.2.0


url_launcher_macos 3.2.0

flutter any
url_launcher_platform_interface ^2.2.0


url_launcher_platform_interface 2.3.2

flutter any
plugin_platform_interface ^2.1.7


url_launcher_web 2.3.1

flutter any
flutter_web_plugins any
url_launcher_platform_interface ^2.2.0
web ^0.5.0


url_launcher_windows 3.1.1

flutter any
url_launcher_platform_interface ^2.2.0


uuid 4.4.0

crypto ^3.0.0
sprintf ^7.0.0
meta ^1.10.0
fixnum ^1.1.0


vector_graphics 1.1.11+1

flutter any
http ^1.0.0
vector_graphics_codec 1.1.11+1


vector_graphics_codec 1.1.11+1
vector_graphics_compiler 1.1.11+1

args ^2.3.0
meta ^1.7.0
path_parsing ^1.0.1
xml ^6.3.0
vector_graphics_codec 1.1.11+1
path ^1.8.0


vector_math 2.1.4
vm_service 13.0.0
web 0.5.1
win32 5.5.0

ffi ^2.1.2


wkt_parser 2.0.0
xdg_directories 1.0.4

meta ^1.3.0
path ^1.8.0


xml 6.5.0

collection ^1.18.0
meta ^1.9.0
petitparser ^6.0.0

Steps to reproduce

Use the recommended code snippet for the auth signing in page. (I use GoRoute so the code is a bit different, but everything around firebase_ui_auth is the same)

          GoRoute(
            path: '/sign-in',
            builder: (BuildContext context, GoRouterState state) {
              return SignInScreen(
                actions: [
                  AuthStateChangeAction<SignedIn>((context, signInState) {
                    debugPrint("AuthState changed: ${signInState.user!.email}");
                    if (signInState.user!.emailVerified) {
                      context.pushReplacement(HomeScreen.route);
                    } else {
                      context.push('/verify-email');
                    }
                  }),
                ],
              );
            },
          ),

Then in the Sign In page, click "Register", fill in valid credential and click the "Register" button.

Expected Behavior

At least something will happen to indicate that the registration is successful. Either jumping to the email verification page, or the sign in page, or some hint appears.

If nothing happens, the documentation should highlight this intended design, and add post-registration handling in the example code snippet.

Actual Behavior

1. Nothing happens after successfully adding the user data to the firebase auth database.
2. The firebase_ui_auth documentation does not clarify this intended(?) behavior, or tell developers how to customize the post-registration behavior.

Additional Information

I post this issue as a "bug" because the documentation says nothing about this phenomenon. So I doubt whether it is really intended that nothing happens after users click the Register button.

Some suggested solutions are:

1. After I looked deeply into the source code, I found that the AuthState SigningUp is issued before trying to write the user credential in the database, and UserCreated is issued after successfully written the user credential in the database. So below is my solution, and I suggest the example code snippet in the library documentation also change to similar (except for the use of GoRoute)

          GoRoute(
            path: '/sign-in',
            builder: (BuildContext context, GoRouterState state) {
              return SignInScreen(
                actions: [
                  /// SignedIn state happens after a successful signing-in
                  AuthStateChangeAction<SignedIn>((context, signInState) {
                    debugPrint("AuthState changed: ${signInState.user!.email}");
                    if (signInState.user!.emailVerified) {
                      context.pushReplacement(HomeScreen.route);
                    } else {
                      context.push('/verify-email');
                    }
                  }),
                  /// UserCreated state happens after a successful signing-up
                  AuthStateChangeAction<UserCreated>((context, state) {
                    scaffoldMessengerKey.currentState?.showSnackBar(
                      const SnackBar(content: Text("User created. Please sign in now."))
                    );
                    context.push("/verify-email");
                  }),
                ],
              );
            },
          ),

2. I'd suggest the library developers to (optionally) automatically send an email verification after a successful registration. The option may be provided in the constructor of SignInScreen. Moreover, if app developers decided to not verify emails, there can be another option to automatically sign in after a successful registration.
3. Although I haven't tried RegisterScreen yet, it sounds like something similar to SignInScreen. I don't know why are there two ways to provide email registration UI, and why we can't customize the "authSwith" (Register/Sign In text button) on the SignInScreen to use dedicated pages instead.

[github-actions]

Hello 👋, to help manage issues we automatically close stale issues.

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had activity for quite some time. Has this issue been fixed, or does it still require attention?

This issue will be closed in 15 days if no further activity occurs.

Thank you for your contributions.

[github-actions]

Hello 👋, to help manage issues we automatically close stale issues.

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had activity for quite some time. Has this issue been fixed, or does it still require attention?

This issue will be closed in 15 days if no further activity occurs.

Thank you for your contributions.