SceneName in SceneEvent contains inconsistent values

[Edvinas01]

Description

When using automatic scene management, SceneName is inconsistently reported in NetworkSceneManager.OnSceneEvent.

Reproduce Steps

1. Enable automatic scene management
2. Subscribe to NetworkSceneManager.OnSceneEvent in networkManager.OnClientStarted
3. Load a scene via NetworkSceneManager by passing in a full scene path (e.g., Assets/Scenes/GameScene_02.unity)
4. Track SceneEvent.SceneName and SceneEvent.Scene arguments in OnSceneEvent callback

Actual Outcome

SceneEvent.SceneName in some event types contains the full scene path, in some only the scene name.

Expected Outcome

SceneEvent.SceneName should always be consistent - contain the full scene path or the scene name all the time.

Environment

• OS: Windows 10
• Unity Version: 6000.0.47f1
• com.unity.netcode.gameobjects version: 2.3.2
• com.unity.services.multiplayer version: 1.1.2
• Distributed authority, using sessions

Additional Context

I'm using distributed authority:

var multiplayerService = MultiplayerService.Instance;

var options = new SessionOptions
{
    Name = multiplayerSessionNameId,
    MaxPlayers = 10,
    IsPrivate = false,
    IsLocked = false,
}.WithDistributedAuthorityNetwork();

await multiplayerService.CreateOrJoinSessionAsync(multiplayerSessionNameId, options);

Loading the scene as follows:

var scenePath = SceneUtility.GetScenePathByBuildIndex(index);
Debug.Log($"Starting to load scenePath={scenePath}");
sceneManager.LoadScene(scenePath, LoadSceneMode.Additive);

Tracking the OnSceneEvent the following way:

private void OnSceneEvent(SceneEvent sceneEvent)
{
    var sceneName = sceneEvent.SceneName;
    var eventType = sceneEvent.SceneEventType;
    var scene = sceneEvent.Scene;

    Debug.Log($"{eventType}: sceneName={sceneName}, scene.name={scene.name}, scene.path={scene.path}");
}

Log lines that get printed:

Starting to load scenePath=Assets/Scenes/GameScene_02.unity
Load: sceneName=Assets/Scenes/GameScene_02.unity, scene.name=, scene.path=
LoadComplete: sceneName=GameScene_02, scene.name=GameScene_02, scene.path=Assets/Scenes/GameScene_02.unity
LoadEventCompleted: sceneName=GameScene_02, scene.name=, scene.path=

[EmandM]

The LoadScene() function takes either a path or a scene name. All other OnSceneEvent() events are explicitly invoking the event with only the scene name, however Load event on the authority instance (Server or DA host) will instead use the sceneName string that you passed into the LoadScene() function.

By calling LoadScene() as in your example above, the path that you are passing is what is being passed directly into the event.

Do you have further details on the issue you're encountering here?

[Edvinas01]

The LoadScene() function takes either a path or a scene name. All other OnSceneEvent() events are explicitly invoking the event with only the scene name, however Load event on the authority instance (Server or DA host) will instead use the sceneName string that you passed into the LoadScene() function.

By calling LoadScene() as in your example above, the path that you are passing is what is being passed directly into the event.

Do you have further details on the issue you're encountering here?

Wouldn't it make more sense to make sure that sceneName is used in Load event, even if the user provides a scene path? This way each event type would be consistent in all cases. Now the alternative is that I have to treat the Load event separately (e.g., if I have List<string> loadingScenePaths in order to keep track of whats being loaded). I think this makes the API confusing as the variable name lies.

Alternatively I suppose to avoid breaking changes, perhaps documentation needs more clarification on this, since I was confused for a couple of hours when testing this as my loading state would hang as it was not cleaning up due to intermixed paths/names.

[NoelStephensUnity]

That is a good point. The issue is marked for import.

For your use case (and to avoid potentially breaking other projects), would a reasonable compromise be to provide an additional "ScenePath" string within the SceneEvent so you have (consistently) the SceneName and ScenePath populated?

[Edvinas01]

That is a good point. The issue is marked for import.

For your use case (and to avoid potentially breaking other projects), would a reasonable compromise be to provide an additional "ScenePath" string within the SceneEvent so you have (consistently) the SceneName and ScenePath populated?

Having a ScenePath would be ideal I think!

[NoelStephensUnity]

This issue is resolved in NGO v2.4.0 which is now public.
I am closing this issue at this time, but if you run into issues similar to this issue please feel free to re-open it and provide us with additional details.