diff --git a/src/Core/Menus.fs b/src/Core/Menus.fs
index 057a07f..74d3589 100644
--- a/src/Core/Menus.fs
+++ b/src/Core/Menus.fs
@@ -96,7 +96,7 @@ let render (render: 'reactElement RenderApi) (menus: MenuOutput list) =
                     for (isChecked, key, child) in selections do
                         let renderChild (label: string, children) =
                             if isChecked then render.checked'(label, key, children) else render.unchecked(label, key)
-                        let childReact = recur isChecked ((if collapse then collapsedRender key else render), renderChild) child
+                        let childReact = recur (not isChecked) ((if collapse then collapsedRender key else render), renderChild) child
                         childReact
                 ]
             if collapse then
@@ -104,7 +104,7 @@ let render (render: 'reactElement RenderApi) (menus: MenuOutput list) =
             else
                 renderMe(defaultArg label "Choose one:", children)
         | And(label, grants) ->
-            let childReacts = grants |> List.map (recur true (render, render.unconditional))
+            let childReacts = grants |> List.map (recur shortCircuit (render, render.unconditional))
             match label with
             | Some label ->
                 renderMe(label, childReacts)
diff --git a/test/Chargen.Accept.fs b/test/Chargen.Accept.fs
index 5f4cb56..588e7a4 100644
--- a/test/Chargen.Accept.fs
+++ b/test/Chargen.Accept.fs
@@ -234,11 +234,13 @@ let units = testList "Unit.Chargen" [
             pseudoActual
             (Fragment [
                 Checked("Sword and Dagger", key "Sword and Dagger", [
-                    Unchecked("Rapier +4", key "Sword and Dagger-Rapier")
-                    Unchecked("Broadsword +4", key "Sword and Dagger-Broadsword")
-                    Unchecked("Shortsword +4", key "Sword and Dagger-Shortsword")
+                    Checked("Choose one:", key "Sword and Dagger", [
+                        Unchecked("Rapier +4", key "Sword and Dagger-Rapier")
+                        Unchecked("Broadsword +4", key "Sword and Dagger-Broadsword")
+                        Unchecked("Shortsword +4", key "Sword and Dagger-Shortsword")
+                        ])
+                    Checked("Main-gauche +1", key "Sword and Dagger", [])
                     ])
-                Checked("Main-gauche +1", key "Sword and Dagger", [])
                 ])
     ]
 [<Tests>]