You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
When users ask about library behavior, aider cannot access the actual implementation code of dependencies. This forces aider to rely on pre-trained knowledge rather than analyzing the real code users are working with.
This creates three critical issues:
Inaccurate explanations when documentation differs from implementation
Version-specific behaviors cannot be detected (users often work with specific library versions)
Implementation details critical for debugging remain hidden
Proposed Solution
Implement a source code inspection feature that allows aider to:
Directly inspect source code of imported dependencies using introspection tools (such as inspect in Python)
Extract actual implementation code to analyze behavior, not just documentation
Detect version-specific implementation details by analyzing installed code
Generate more accurate explanations based on real code, not pre-trained knowledge
Example
How the source code can be accessed:
# User is wondering about NumPy average implementation details# Instead of guessing, aider would access actual sourceimportinspectimportnumpy.lib.function_baseasfbprint(inspect.getsource(fb.average))
This is the output aider would see after inspection:
When users ask "How does numpy.random.RandomState work internally?" or "What edge cases does pandas.DataFrame.fillna handle?", aider could access the actual implementation rather than rely on documentation summaries.
Limitations
Source navigation across language boundaries (Python → C/C++) – in fact in the numpy example, most functions don't work, because they are implemented in Cython.
Multi-language support: there are differences between languages (Python, Javascript, C#, Rust...) on how are packages accessed and inspected). It would probably need handlers or adapters for each of the supported languages.
Handling compiled libraries where source might not be included
Benefits
More accurate answers about specific version implementations
Better debugging assistance for edge cases
Deeper insights into performance characteristics and implementation details
Reduced hallucination when explaining complex library behavior
Implementation details
I am a newcomer here, so I am leaving actual implementation details open to discussion.
This capability could be implemented as a "tool" next to the already existing search capability.
Advanced functionality: repomap could be enhanced by inspection of crucial dependencies.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Feature: Source Code Inspection for Dependencies
Problem
When users ask about library behavior, aider cannot access the actual implementation code of dependencies. This forces aider to rely on pre-trained knowledge rather than analyzing the real code users are working with.
This creates three critical issues:
Proposed Solution
Implement a source code inspection feature that allows aider to:
Example
How the source code can be accessed:
This is the output aider would see after inspection:
When users ask "How does numpy.random.RandomState work internally?" or "What edge cases does pandas.DataFrame.fillna handle?", aider could access the actual implementation rather than rely on documentation summaries.
Limitations
Benefits
Implementation details
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: